1999
- The House Spider & Other Strange Visitors by Kurt Newton
- Demons, Freaks and Other Abnormalities by Michael Laimo
- Burnt Offerings by Shane Ryan Staley
2000
- I Love You and There is Nothing You Can Do About It by Gerard Houarner
- Human Oddities by Barbara Malenky
- Chocolate Jesus and Other Weird Perversions by Shane Ryan Staley
- Terror Incognita by Jeffrey Thomas
- Shoggoth Cacciatore and Other Eldritch Entrees by Mark McLaughlin
- Up, Out of Cities that Blow Hot and Cold by Charlee Jacob
- Cage of Bones and Other Deadly Obsessions by John Everson
2001
- The Dead Inn edited by Shane Ryan Staley
- Smoke Signals by Octavio Ramos Jr.
- Tales of Love and Death by W. H. Pugmire
- Cobwebs and Whispers by Scott Thomas
- Heretics by Greg F. Gifune
- “I’ll Be Damned” by Shane Ryan Staley
- 4 x 4 by Brian Keene, Geoff Cooper, Michael Oliveri and Michael T. Huyck Jr.
2002
- Dark Testament edited by Shane Ryan Staley
- Dark Demons by Kurt Newton
- Maternal Instinct by J. F. Gonzalez
- Guises by Charlee Jacob
- Atmosphere by Michael Laimo
- Visions Through A Shattered Lens by Gerard Houarner
2003
- Mean Sheep by Tom Piccirilli
- The Rising by Brian Keene
- Punktown by Jeffrey Thomas
- Sesqua Valley and Other Haunts by W. H. Pugmire
- Broken On The Wheel Of Sex by Jack Ketchum
- No Rest At All by Brian Keene
- Up, Out of Cities that Blow Hot and Cold by Charlee Jacob
- The Bleeding Season by Greg F. Gifune
- Dragonfly by Brian Knight
- The Logan Chronicles by William F. Nolan
- The Seventh Victim by Charlee Jacob
- All the Lonely People by David B. Silva
- Hexes by Tom Piccirilli
2004
- Host by Bryan Eytcheson
- The Man Who Killed Kew Gardens by Brian Lumley
- Dreadful Delineations by John Maclay
- Sixteen Sucking Stories by Brian Lumley
- Soma by Charlee Jacob
- The Attraction by Douglas Clegg
- Fear of Gravity by Brian Keene
- A Puppet Show For No One by Jeffrey Thomas
- The Arms of the Sun by Jeffrey Thomas
- Grave Markings by Michael Arnzen
- Down To Sleep by Greg F. Gifune
- Crota by Owl Goingback
- The Rising: Necrophobia by Brian Keene, Brett McBean, Michael Oliveri, and John Urbancik
- The God of Foulness by Matt Cardin
- Nether: Improper Bedtime Stories by Scott Thomas and Jeffrey Thomas
- Honey Is Sweeter Than Blood by Jeffrey Thomas
- Shadows of Flesh by Scott Thomas
- Ravenous Ghosts by Kealan Patrick Burke
- New Dark Voices by Michael Oliveri, Gene O’Neill and John Urbancik
- The Many by David B. Silva
- An Outsider by John Pelan
- Deathrealms edited by Stephen Mark Rainey
- Motivational Shrieker by Mark McLaughlin
- The Deceased by Tom Piccirilli
- The Parasite by Ramsey Campbell
- Covenant by John Everson
- Sleepwalker by Michael Laimo
- Scary Rednecks: The Appalachian Omnibus by Weston Ochse and David Whitman
- AAAIIIEEE!!! by Jeffrey Thomas
- Sympathy For The Devil: The Best of Hail Saten Vol. 1 by Brian Keene
2005
- City of the Dead by Brian Keene
- Far Out: The Incredible Adventures of Sam Space by William F. Nolan
- Scarecrow Gods by Weston Ochse
- Hush by Tim Lebbon and Gavin Williams
- Body Counting by David Whitman
- Broken Angel by Brian Knight
- Deathgrip by Brian Hodge
- Descent by Sandy DeLuca
- My Eyes are Nailed, but I Still See by David Niall Wilson and Brett Alexander Savory
- A Lower Deep by Tom Piccirilli
- Vestal by Charlee Jacob
- Earthworm Gods by Brian Keene
- The Doll Who Ate His Mother by Ramsey Campbell
- Deep Night by Greg F. Gifune
- Slime After Slime by Mark McLaughlin
- Night of the Daemon: Night Trilogy Part 3 by Harry Shannon
- Prodigal by Melanie Tem
2006
- Thirteen Specimens by Jeffrey Thomas
- Failure by John Everson
- Running With The Devil: The Best of Hail Saten Vol. 2 by Brian Keene
- In Delirium edited by Brian Keene
- The Rising: Selected Scenes From the End of the World by Brian Keene
- The Dark Underbelly of Hymns by Martin Mundt
- The Pines by Robert Dunbar
- Blindsided by Barry Hoffman
- Scary Rednecks and Other Inbred Horrors by Weston Ochse and David Whitman
- Imprint by Patrick Lestewka
- Hacks by Brian Knight
- Excavation by Steve Rasnic Tem
- The Wishnik by Kurt Newton
- Jigsaw by Gord Rollo
- His Pain by Wrath James White
- Demon! by William F. Nolan
- Collected Tales of the Baja Express by Gene O’Neill
- Clickers by J. F. Gonzalez
- My Soul to Keep by Tananarive Due
2007
- The Rising: Death in Four Colors by Brian Keene
- Recalled to Life: The Cycle of the Aegis Trilogy Book 1 by Weston Ochse
- The Sinister Mr. Corpse by Jeff Strand
- Untcigahunk: Stories and Myths of the Little Brothers by Rick Hautala
- Ghoul by Brian Keene
- Sacrifice by John Everson
- Clickers II: The Next Wave by J. F. Gonzalez and Brian Keene
- Pickman’s Motel by Mark McLaughlin
- The Shore by Robert Dunbar
- Demogorgon by Brian Lumley
- Dominion by Greg F. Gifune
- God’s End by Michael McBride
- The New Fear: The Best of Hail Saten Vol. 3 by Brian Keene
- Dead Sea by Brian Keene
- Prototype by Brian Hodge
- Blood Wish by Michael McBride
- No Further Messages by Brett Alexander Savory
- The Demonologist by Michael Laimo
2008
- In Delirium II edited by John Everson
- The Condemned by David Jack Bell
- Oogie Boogie Bounce by M. Stephen Lukac
- Oogie Boogie Central by M. Stephen Lukac
- The Infected by Michael McBride
- Blood in Electric Blue by Greg F. Gifune
- Gleefully Macabre Tales by Jeff Strand
- Divagations by John Maclay
- Suckers by J.A. Konrath & Jeff Strand
- Saying Uncle by Greg F. Gifune
- Earthworm Gods: Selected Scenes from the End of the World by Brian Keene
- Dead and Gone by Harry Shannon
- Passenger by Ronald Damien Malfi
- The Golden Thread: The Cycle of the Aegis Trilogy Book 2 by Weston Ochse
- Ghost Walk by Brian Keene
- Manhattan Grimoire by Sandy DeLuca
2009
- Broken Shadows by Tim Waggoner
- New Dark Voices 2 edited by Brian Keene
- Children of Chaos by Greg F. Gifune
- Bloodletting by Michael McBride
- Unhappy Endings by Brian Keene
- Benjamin’s Parasite by Jeff Strand
- Reservoir Gods by Brian Knight
- Primitive by J. F. Gonzalez
- The Girl In The Woods by David Jack Bell
2010
- Long After Dark by Greg F. Gifune
- Clickers III: Dagon Rising by J. F. Gonzalez & Brian Keene
- Creeptych by John Everson
- Innocents Lost by Michael McBride
- Immun3 by Michael McBride
- The Living And The Dead by Greg F. Gifune
2011
- Back From The Dead by J. F. Gonzalez
- The Separation by Ronald Malfi
- Darkness Conjured by Sandy DeLuca
- Cradle Lake by Ronald Malfi
- Bleed For You by Michael Louis Calvillo
- Among The Living by Steve Rasnic Tem
- The Dark Ones by Bryan Smith
- Shadowed by Bill Gauthier
- It Drinks Blood by J. F. Gonzalez
- Fangboy by Jeff Strand
- Beyond The Door by Jeffrey Thomas
- Dreams of The Ragman by Greg F. Gifune
- Nursery Rhymes 4 Dead Children by Lee Thompson
- Dead Tree Forest by Brett McBean
- Unearthed by Gina Ranalli
- The Pumpkin Man by John Everson
- Nancy Goats by Weston Ochse
- Vehicles by Patrick Lestewka
- Predatory Instinct by Michael McBride
- Fear Me by Tim Curran
- Bloodrush by Bryan Smith
- Iron Butterflies Rust by Lee Thompson
- Into Hell by William Ollie
- Midnight Solitaire by Greg F. Gifune
- Darkness Falls by Allan Leverone
- Skullbelly by Ronald Malfi
- Black Mercy Falls by Christopher Fulbright & Angeline Hawkes
- Bleed With Me by Maurice Broaddus
